Serving New York style pizza, subs, calzones, and more. Also offers carryout, delivery, and catering.
Frequently Asked Questions
Places You Should Consider
News & Articles
8 Restaurants You Must Order Delivery From in Tampa
The Best Downtown Tampa Restaurants for Brunch, Lunch & Dinner!
Locally Owned Restaurants in Tampa
Restaurants in Downtown Tampa with Delivery and Takeout
Places To Eat On A Budget in Tampa
The Most Instagram-Worthy Restaurants and Foods in Tampa!
Happy 4/20 in Tampa! Find The Best Munchies Deals For The Holiday Here!
Cheap Date Night Ideas in Tampa Bay for Valentine's Day 2018
Add to My Connections
Say Something or Ask a Question about Eddie and Sams New York Pizza
Recommended Ratings & Reviews
Absolutely love this place! Very original and delicious flavors. The Chicken Parmesan pizza is amazing!
Pros: Delicious food Quick service Amazing atmosphere Heart of downtown
I go for the pizza with chicken and jalopeno loaded with some crushed red pepper, but you can never go wrong with a good pepperoni pizza pie.
Pros: If you like greasy New York pizza, then you will love Eddie and Sams New York Pizza. Some of the best pizza in Tampa and convenient for those working in Downtown Tampa.
Cons: Parking on the streets in downtown are a hit or miss during the day, but if you can walk here then you are in for a treat.
Great pizza at an excellent cost can be found at Eddie and Sam's. Get your favorites by the pie or the slice, and enjoy a tasty calzone while you're visiting.
Best pizza in the city...and it's not even close!! The lasagne pizza is a life changer!! Great white pizza too! Very cool corner of downtown.
Pros: LASAGNE PIZZA!! Lots of pizza options. Big slices. Good value. Authentic New York pizzeria feel.
Cons: Pay to park in the lot across the street.
I love Eddie and Sams! It’s the best place to get a good slice of pizza in Tampa! They’re buffalo chicken slice and chicken parmesan slice are my favorites! But their cheese is also amazing and they have a lunch deal for two slices and a drink for I believe 6.99!
Pros: Buffalo Chicken Slice, Chicken Parmesan Slice, Selling pizza by the slice.
Cons: Sometimes it can be hard to find parking... But it’s alwYs worth the wait for a space !
It's real NY pizza, and it's really good. Tons of different things to try, but I love the white. Authentic, real, and delicious with garlic!
Pros: Awesome NY Style pizza you can't beat anywhere in Florida.
Cons: Can get a bit busy at lunch, and if you're parking it can be a bit of a pain. But if you work downtown, walk over and love it!
The place to be if you're looking for an Authentic New York slice. They actually ship water from New York down to make the dough, which is noticeably great, especially for a local pizza. Gets a little crowded, but they've expanded with a gelato shop, so there was ample seating when I visited.
Pros: Nice spot for a great slice of quality pizza without breaking the bank.
Cons: Expect to pay for parking if you're driving.
Pros: Ohhh myyyy gagaaaa!!! THE Best place for pizza in Tampa by far! Try literally any of the pizza slices and the stromboli! Amazing!
Cons: Parking downtown is terrible!